Was Jesus crucified on Wednesday or Friday?
ContestedTexts of equal or higher authority genuinely pull both ways — SAM names both sides.
The text is genuinely contested: narrator accounts in all four Gospels fit a Friday crucifixion naturally, but Jesus' own Tier 2 statement of "three days and three nights" is difficult to reconcile with Friday-to-Sunday without an unstated assumption, and John's "special Sabbath" opens the door to a Wednesday or Thursday date.
Tier 5/3 narrator texts (Mark 15:42 calling the burial day "the fore-sabbath"; Luke 23:54-56 describing the Sabbath drawing near and the women resting) point naturally to Friday. But Jesus' own Tier 2 words in Matthew 12:40 — "three days and three nights in the heart of the earth" — require an unstated harmonizing assumption (partial-day counting) to fit Friday-to-Sunday, and John 19:31's "special Sabbath" (Tier 3) combined with Leviticus 23's feast-sabbaths (Tier 1) allows for a mid-week crucifixion. Neither side can be read as DIRECT without an assumption the text does not state.
The unresolved tension: The text does not state which sabbath Mark's prosabbaton ("fore-sabbath") refers to — the weekly Sabbath or the feast-sabbath of 15 Nisan — nor does it state that "three days and three nights" uses inclusive partial-day counting. Both of these are the specific things the text is silent on, and resolving either one would resolve the question.
…and 23 more verses weighed in the full analysis.
See SAM's complete analysis — every verse it weighs, ranked by who is speaking (God, Jesus, the apostles), with the full step-by-step reasoning and word-for-word verified citations. New accounts get two free questions.
See the full analysis in SAM →SAM answers from primary-source texts only, weighing each verse by its authority tier. Every quotation is verified word-for-word. How the method works →